logo

52 pages 1 hour read

American Wolf: A True Story of Survival and Obsession in the West

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 4-5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 4 Summary: “Killers”

By 2010, the popularity of Yellowstone’s wolves in nearby Crandall has hit a nadir. Locals like Louie Cary hold forth from their bar stools to decry the wolves’ return and their effect on local business. Cary is a hunt outfitter and tour guide, the kind of operation Crandall used to support easily. He maintains two hunting camps at the park’s edge and charges thousands of dollars to out-of-towners who want to bag an elk, preferably a bull for its desirable horns.

This used to be no problem. The Yellowstone elk numbered around 19,000 before the wolves, but in recent years their number has dwindled to around 6,000. Game officials point to multiple causes for this drop, including development, drought, and the extension of the elk-hunting season in Montana (a popular decision at the time). But it seems likely wolves have affected the numbers too. Beyond that, elk that venture out of the park are harder to hunt. Predation has made them far more cautious, so that Cary and other hunters must head deeper into the woods to find them, whereas previously they could lure them into the open.

Cary is a long-term opponent of the wolves’ reintroduction. In fact, some of his clients spotted the injured Druids Pack wolves in 1997, though Cary maintains none of them were responsible for their shooting. Federal investigators grilled Cary and his clients but reached an impasse. Now, Cary is wary of federal inference, as his hunting camps are located on federal land for which he requires numerous permits. His business overall has become precarious. From nine outfitters in the town, only three are left. And, as elk numbers fall, the Wyoming Game and Fish Department has slashed the numbers of hunting licenses available to nonresidents to only 20 per year. With Cary nearing 70 years old, his business is hanging on by a thread.

Meanwhile, for a local hunter like Steven Turnbull, the picture is not much rosier. He also faces an annual scramble for a hunting permit and has to compete with the well-heeled tourists Cary brings to town for the fewer elk that come through. Ranchers, meanwhile, put pressure on Animal Damage Control, the federal agency responsible for killing animals that attack livestock, to cull wolves—a conflict that stretches back into human history.

Wolves were once the most widespread mammal on earth. Early farmers in northern Africa had to protect their livestock from them. This conflict replicated itself anywhere humans raised livestock and led to the many idioms that feature the wolf, as keeping one’s livelihood safe from predators dominated rural life and conversation. It was the domestication of wolves into dogs that, somewhat ironically, helped humans gain the upper hand in this struggle. Dogs helped defend or round up livestock—think of the shepherd tending his flock—and ultimately helped humans supplant wolves as the world’s most widespread mammal. Still, the wolf’s place in Western culture was assured. As the idea of the “flock” came to mean early Christians, too, so the wolf, its predator, became a symbol of evil. Later, myths like the werewolf cemented the wolf’s diabolic status.

While there are rational reasons for Crandall’s residents to be sour on wolves, their ire follows a pattern of anti-wolf sentiment that goes back thousands of years. Turnbull and other hunters give excited wolf-spotting tourists short shrift. For them, the wolves are killers.

Chapter 5 Summary: “The King of Currumpaw”

It is May 2010. O-Six has denned to give birth to four pups from 755. She is holed up above a grassy bowl on a plateau above Lamar Canyon, which joins Little America to the full Lamar Valley. She must raise her litter to hold her new territory and help her pack feed itself, but it’s tedious work. One day, for example, she spends seven hours jousting with a passing grizzly bear and her two cubs, desperately trying to lead them away from her den. A signal paw swipe from the mother could kill O-Six, but she must distract the bears before they can excavate her pups from the hillside to feed on them. It is an exhausting fight for their survival.

By the end of May, the pups can leave the den to frolic in the bowl below. The three adult wolves develop new routines and dynamics to raise them. Father 755 helps O-Six keep passing bears away and also hunts with 754. Sometimes the pair drag elk meat back from miles away, a cumbersome and exhausting task. Often, instead, the adult wolves gorge on kills, then regurgitate semi-digested meat for the pups, in the way adult birds feed their chicks.

As the pups grow, O-Six moves their den to the plateau’s eastern side, hoping to alleviate the risk of bear attacks. Moving the playful pups—two male, two female—goes well, and the young wolves join their parents and uncle in a happy howl as they survey the territory before them. It will become their home, if they survive until adulthood.

Of course, wolf-spotters are surveying O-Six’s plateau from the opposite direction. Ever since the cubs made an appearance, the opposing hilltop has been packed with spotters watching them play and develop. Project officials have officially dubbed the family the Lamar Canyon Pack, though fans shorten the name to the Lamars. By the summer, O-Six is Yellowstone’s biggest star.

Rick, Laurie, and Doug are ever present at these jamborees, with Rick talking to the park’s visitors and helping them spy the wolves in action. Rick’s real dream, though, is to write a new book (he wrote one previously arguing for wolves’ reintroduction) that will chart their successful return to the West. He and his fellow spotters can’t help but be enthralled by the wolves they watch daily, learning their habits and their personalities. Rick knows he needs to capture such details to win over hearts and minds.

The scale of that challenge beyond the park’s borders is becoming ever clearer. A first hunting season in Montana has proved deadly for park wolves. Within three weeks, hunters killed four out of 10 wolves from the Cottonwood Creek Pack. The dead included both the pack’s alphas (male and female), meaning they would drift toward an uncertain fate. The only two wolves in the pack with research collars—visitor favorites 527 and 716—were shot, too, leaving project officials with no way to track the remaining wolves. Rick has heard 527’s carcass is on display behind a bar near Gardiner. The town is not far from the northern end of Buffalo Plateau—home to O-Six’s current den—and is a focal point of anti-wolf sentiment.

Rick’s best hope for O-Six is that she moves into the Lamar Valley proper, if the weakened Druids relinquish it. That way, she and her offspring are more likely to roam to the east instead, into Wyoming, where authorities have yet to declare a wolf-hunting season. But it is only a matter of time before they do. The sport is proving popular. In total, the first season in Idaho and Montana yielded 258 dead wolves, many of them less heralded or beloved than Yellowstone’s.

In late winter, O-Six eventually kills her Druid nemesis White Line, who is in poor health and unable to take out her rival. The wolf-spotters who witness the bloody battle even get a firsthand glance of O-Six later chasing a bull elk across the road through the Lamar Valley within 200 yards of the packed car park. She is increasingly assertive and becoming a draw to Yellowstone’s wolf fans.

One of the witnesses that day is retired school teacher Laurie Lyman. She moved to the area in 2006 and lives near Rick in Silver Gate. She’s even part of his informal group of wolf-spotters, known as “Rick Radio,” who stay in constant contact every day. Laurie writes wolf articles on a local website and is a popular part of Yellowstone’s growing wolf-watching community.

Another recent transplant is Doug McLaughlin from Washington State. He has a great knack for spotting the wolves, and Rick often leans on him when the rudimentary telemetry from the wolves’ collars fails. This trio become firm friends, and while the park biologists categorize the wolves in terms of their weights, diets, ranges, and so on, Rick, Laurie and Doug follow their lives, understand their behavior, and even nickname them. In fact, it is Laurie who christens O-Six.

It is also Laurie’s account of the battle between O-Six and White Line, and the ensuing bull elk chase, that burnishes O-Six’s reputation as one of the park’s stars. When Rick retrieves White Line’s body for the park biologists, he can’t help but feel that her demise is the nail in the Druids’ coffin. He is saddened, too, by a levelling off in the park’s wolf population, from a giddy high of 174 wolves to around 100 now. Project biologists predicted this would happen, predators and prey balanced out. But it is a blow for Rick and fellow watchers who were accustomed to the Lamar Valley’s lively life until now.

The wolves face a new threat outside the park too. After drawn-out court battles, the US Fish and Wildlife Service delisted wolves as endangered species in the Northern Rockies, putting management of their numbers in state control. Montana and Idaho instituted their first legal wolf-hunting seasons, with Wyoming hoping to follow suit. The wolves remain protected within Yellowstone’s boundaries, but beyond them, they are no longer the apex predator. Project officials have culled wolves that preyed on livestock to fulfil a promise to local farmers made at the initial reintroduction, but they hoped it would ensure the wolves’ acceptance in the Northern Rockies. This has not been the case.

Chapters 4-5 Analysis

These chapters characterize the different sides in the battle over Yellowstone’s wolves and, in so doing, sharpen the lines of the conflict between them. Readers learn more about anti-wolf forces like Turnbull, Louie Cary, and ranchers in the regions around Yellowstone. The concentration of these characters in the town of Crandall paints it as a locus of anti-wolf feeling. This is effective foreshadowing of the fate that befalls O-Six in the town.

An important aspect here emerges in Chapter 4, where Blakeslee carefully restates Crandall residents’ rational arguments against the Yellowstone wolves and examines some of their evidence for the animals’ impact on the town. But he also delves into the often emotional tenure of anti-wolf sentiment, the hatred or fear that people seem to feel regarding the species. He manages to give a succinct history of human-wolf relations that explains the wolf’s place in the human psyche—including mention of idioms and myths. His point is that the wolf became a shorthand or metaphor for deep-seated human emotions, with some Christians even seeing the wolf as diabolic. Even in the 21st century, the human reaction to wolves might not be entirely rational. This lends the story an extra layer of pathos, by increasing the sense of injustice over human treatment of wolves. Do officials and hunters want to manage them according to some scientific rationale? Or do they, on some level, want to persecute them? Blakeslee poses these questions here for the reader to discern.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools