57 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Harlem Renaissance was an explosion of Black literary, musical, and artistic production that occurred between 1917 and 1935. Based in Harlem, New York, the writers, musicians, and visual artists from this important period sought to advance the cause of Black civil rights through representations of what notable writer Alain Locke termed “The New Negro.” Working to counter common stereotypes and present an alternative to racist representations of African Americans in popular culture, Harlem Renaissance writers instead depicted their Black subjects in a positive, humanizing light. The literary project of the Harlem Renaissance was twofold: Writers wanted to provide a window into the Black experience in modern-day America and showcase the literary talent of their communities, proving that Black-authored texts deserved a place in the American literary canon.
Although its origins are complex and multifaceted, two critical sociohistorical phenomena laid the groundwork for the Harlem Renaissance: the “Red Summer” of 1919 and the Great Migration. The summer of 1919, which came on the heels of the Russian Revolution and the conclusion of World War I, was a period of intense racial discord and brutal violence in the United States. Many Black Americans fought in the war, and although they enjoyed recognition and acceptance in the armed forces, they returned to an often hostile country marked by inequality and prejudice. They were subject to widespread racism, vied with white Americans for a limited number of newly created industrial jobs, and were often the targets of violence. Nineteen-hundred-and-nineteen saw a horrific number of lynchings, and race riots exploded in many major cities. It was against the backdrop of this racialized violence that Black Americans (and Harlem Renaissance authors) fought for humanity, recognition, and respect.
The Great Migration was one of the largest population shifts in United States history. Beginning in 1910 and continuing through the 1960s, more than 6 million African Americans moved from rural areas in the South to northern cities. There were several factors behind this period of dramatic immigration; namely, Black Americans sought new economic opportunities in the rapidly industrializing North and wanted to escape the segregationist policies of the Jim Crow South. (“Jim Crow” refers to a set of racist laws, policies, and ordinances that perpetuated inequality during the Reconstruction era.) The Great Migration contributed to Harlem becoming the center of Black culture in the 1920s. For the first time in American history, the largest groups of Black Americans were concentrated in cities, especially in neighborhoods like Harlem. There, African Americans found jobs, increased educational opportunities, places to congregate, and avenues for personal and cultural expression.
The Harlem Renaissance unfolded over three distinct phases. The first, typically dated from 1917 to 1923, was characterized by the development of “the New Negro Movement,” so named by Alain Locke in his canonical essay “The New Negro.” Locke argued that the “greatest rehabilitation” of the image of Black America “would rest on the revaluation by white and black alike of the Negro in terms of his artistic endowments and cultural contributions” (Locke, Alain. “The New Negro.” The Portable Harlem Renaissance Reader, edited by David Levering Lewis, Penguin, 1994, p. 50). Writers from this first wave argued that their artistic contributions to American art and letters would help Black Americans gain recognition and respect. The second phase, lasting from 1923 to 1925, was dominated by voices from the civil rights establishment such as the NAACP, and their work evidences a distinct civil-rights ideology. Writers from both the first and second waves felt strongly that Black-authored texts should depict African Americans as upstanding, hardworking, church-going citizens. They believed that such representation was needed to counter prevailing stereotypes about Black Americans.
The third and final phase, lasting from 1926-1935, challenged the norms and values established by the first and second waves. Writers such as Wallace Thurman, Zora Neale Hurston, and Langston Hughes rebelled against the idea that Black authors should depict African Americans solely as respectable, reputable individuals. They argued that the “authentic” Black experience in America was more complex than that, and representations of African Americans should include those in the working classes, those living on the margins of society, and those whose life experiences did not conform to prevailing notions of straight-laced respectability. The Harlem Renaissance is generally thought to have ended by the 1935 Harlem riots, although questions about Black identity, authenticity, and African American cultural values would work their way into successive Black literary movements. Classic texts from the Harlem Renaissance such as Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God, Jean Toomer’s Cane, Langston Hughes’s The Weary Blues, Nella Larson’s Passing, and Claude McKay’s Home to Harlem are still widely read and taught and have become an important part of the American literary canon.
Born in 1902 in Salt Lake City, Utah, Wallace Thurman became one of the most prominent figures in the Harlem Renaissance before dying young from tuberculosis in 1934. Although Thurman wrote essays and worked as a publisher and editor, he is primarily remembered as a novelist. The Blacker The Berry: A Novel of Negro Life is his best-known and most widely read text.
After bouncing around the West and briefly attending the University of Utah and the University of Southern California, Thurman moved to Harlem in 1925. There, he came to challenge the prevailing idea that Black-authored writing had a responsibility to portray African Americans as hardworking, upstanding citizens to counter damaging anti-Black stereotypes. Thurman, along with other key third-wave figures from the Harlem Renaissance, argued that Black writers should be free to depict Black life in America as it really was: complex, varied, and not always conforming to strict morality codes. Together, these writers sought to show both the highs and the lows of the early 20th-century Black experience and avoid the trap of producing literature focused primarily on garnering approval from white audiences.
Thurman was one of the collaborating founders of Fire!! Devoted to the Younger Negro Artists, a short-lived but prominent literary journal that showcased the work of Black writers who were not bound by a desire to use art for the sake of civil rights and social advancement. Old-guard figures such as W. E. B. Du Bois were scandalized by the collection of stories and vignettes in Fire, objecting to their portrayals of “low” class life, unrestricted (and in some cases gay) sexuality, and lack of interest in respectability. His other prominent work, the 1932 novel The Infants of Spring, satirized life in Harlem and is widely read as a not-so-flattering, thinly veiled critique of many Harlem Renaissance key figures.
Thurman’s interest in depicting the good and the bad of the Black experience is evident in both the characters and setting of The Blacker the Berry. Emma Lou is a complex, at times contradictory character who wrestles with racism, colorism, respectability, and identity development. She is the kind of flawed character whom Thurman argued so passionately should be included in Black-authored writing, and she embodies the idea that African American authors should be as free as their white counterparts to create fully formed, life-like figures.
Thurman also did not eschew depictions of vice, which establishes him as part of the forward-thinking, anti-establishment third wave. The Harlem of The Blacker the Berry is a space of cabarets, bars, and gambling houses. Men throw dice on corners, and Harlemites drink and dance with abandon. Thurman does not condemn alcohol, “loose” morals, or the nightclub scene. Rather, he paints a rich portrait of what life in Harlem was really like and asks his readers to see African American culture not through the limiting prism of respectability but as a complex and beautiful tapestry.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: